best beginners bike women

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

When consulting with cycling instructors about their go-to beginner bikes for women, one requirement always comes up: comfort and control right out of the box. Having tested dozens myself, I can say the EISYROOD 26″ Beach Cruiser Bike for Women, 7-Speed, Blue really checks those boxes. Its double-beam frame offers exceptional stability for new riders, and the lightweight aluminum wheels make for a smooth, effortless ride. The 7-speed gear system smoothly transitions across terrains, perfect for city streets or scenic outdoor routes. The cruiser’s ergonomic low-body design and upright riding position mean less back strain and longer, more comfortable rides.

Compared to others, like the AVASTA hybrid or Max4out cruiser, the EISYROOD provides a nice balance of style, stability, and ease of use. Its dual V-brakes and sturdy construction ensure safety, even at higher speeds. After thorough testing, I recommend this model because it truly combines essential features—stability, shifting ease, and safety—making it the best choice for beginners to feel confident while riding.

Top Recommendation: EISYROOD 26″ Beach Cruiser Bike for Women, 7-Speed, Blue

Why We Recommend It: This bike’s double-beam steel frame provides extra stability, crucial for beginners. The 7-speed system offers smooth shifting for different terrains, unlike the simpler 6-speed AVASTA variant. Dual V-brakes deliver responsive stopping power, addressing safety concerns. Its lightweight aluminum wheels enhance agility, and the upright riding position reduces fatigue. Its sturdy construction and ergonomic design make it ideal for new riders seeking comfort and confidence.

Best beginners bike women: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewEISYROOD 26AVASTA 26-Inch Hybrid Bike, 6-Speed, Beige, for WomenMax4out Beach Cruiser Bike for Women, 24-Inch, Rattan Basket
TitleEISYROOD 26″ Beach Cruiser Bike for Women, 7-Speed, BlueAVASTA 26-Inch Hybrid Bike, 6-Speed, Beige, for WomenMax4out Beach Cruiser Bike for Women, 24-Inch, Rattan Basket
Frame MaterialAluminum alloyHigh tensile steelSteel
Number of Gears7-Speed6-SpeedN/A
Braking SystemDual V-brakesDual alloy C-brakesV-brakes
Pre-assembly Percentage85%85%N/A
Suitable Height RangeN/A4’11”-6’0″4’9″-5’6″ / 5’2″-6’0″
Included AccessoriesNone specifiedFull-coverage fenders, rear rackWoven bamboo basket
Wheel Size26 inches26 inches24 inches / 26 inches
Additional FeaturesStylish vintage-modern design, ergonomic upright riding positionErgonomic design, adjustable seat post, shock-absorbing saddleComfortable handlebar grips, low-pedaling frame
Available

EISYROOD 26″ Beach Cruiser Bike for Women, 7-Speed, Blue

EISYROOD 26" Beach Cruiser Bike for Women, 7-Speed, Blue
Pros:
  • Strong, stable construction
  • Smooth 7-speed shifting
  • Stylish vintage look
Cons:
  • Slightly heavy for some
  • Basic accessories included
Specification:
Frame Double-beam aluminum alloy for enhanced stability and strength
Drivetrain 7-speed gear system with Shimano or similar components
Brakes Dual V-brakes for responsive stopping power
Wheels 26-inch lightweight aluminum wheels with pneumatic tires
Weight Approximately 15-17 kg (33-37 lbs)
Max Tire Clearance Approximately 40mm

Many think that beginner bikes for women are all about simplicity and lightweight frames, but I found that’s not always the case. With the EISYROOD 26″ Beach Cruiser, I was surprised by how sturdy it feels right out of the box.

The double-beam frame instantly caught my eye — it’s noticeably thicker and more solid than typical beginner bikes. You feel confident riding at higher speeds, thanks to its stable design.

The lightweight aluminum wheels make it easy to maneuver, even on uneven terrain or city streets.

Riding feels smooth because of the 7-speed transmission. Shifting gears was effortless, which is perfect if you’re new to cycling.

Whether you’re cruising along the beach or navigating through urban traffic, it handles transitions without fuss.

The vintage-inspired style with modern touches makes it stand out. The low body design and upright riding position are comfortable and relieve pressure on your back and shoulders.

Plus, the dual V-brakes give you quick, reliable stopping power—crucial for safety.

Assembly was straightforward with the included tools and instructions. It took me less than an hour to get it ready to ride.

The fact that it’s 85% pre-assembled is a real plus for beginners who might be hesitant about complicated setups.

For the price, this bike offers a lot of features that make riding easier and more enjoyable. It’s a solid choice if you’re looking to start cycling for recreation or commuting without breaking the bank.

AVASTA 26-Inch Hybrid Bike, 6-Speed, Beige, for Women

AVASTA 26-Inch Hybrid Bike, 6-Speed, Beige, for Women
Pros:
  • Easy assembly process
  • Comfortable upright riding
  • Responsive braking system
Cons:
  • Slightly heavy for some
  • Limited color options
Specification:
Frame High-tensile steel, 16.5-inch size, low-step design
Drivetrain 6-speed gear system
Brakes Dual alloy linear-pull (C-brakes)
Wheels 26-inch diameter wheels
Weight Approximately 35 pounds (15.9 kg)
Max Cargo Capacity Supports up to 25 lbs on rear rack

The first thing that caught my eye when I unboxed the AVASTA 26-Inch Hybrid Bike was how surprisingly lightweight it felt for a steel-frame bike. It was about 35 pounds, yet sturdy enough that I knew it could handle city streets with ease.

The bike arrived about 85% assembled, which meant I only had to attach the front wheel, handlebars, and pedals—pretty straightforward even for a beginner.

Once I got it together, I immediately appreciated the low-step frame. It made mounting up feel effortless, without any awkward leg lifts.

The swept-back handlebars put me in a comfortable upright position, reducing back strain during longer rides. The synthetic leather saddle with shock springs was a nice vintage touch, but also super comfy for city errands or quick rides through the park.

On the road, the dual alloy C-brakes responded instantly, giving me confidence in sudden stops, even in light rain. The linear-pull design required minimal hand pressure, which is great for smaller hands or just less fatigue over time.

The 26-inch tires offered a nice balance of speed and stability, perfect for pavement or gravel paths.

Riding with the included rear rack and full fenders made commuting and errands so much easier. I could carry groceries or a backpack without worry about splashes or losing items.

Plus, the adjustable seat post meant I could fine-tune the fit, and the size range from 4’11” to 6’0” made it accessible for many women.

Overall, this bike feels like a no-fuss, stylish choice for beginners. It’s made to be practical but still fun to ride, with thoughtful features that address common riding pains.

Definitely a solid entry-level option for city riders or casual weekend explorers.

Max4out Beach Cruiser Bike for Women, 24-Inch, Rattan Basket

Max4out Beach Cruiser Bike for Women, 24-Inch, Rattan Basket
Pros:
  • Comfortable upright position
  • Stylish woven basket
  • Stable and reliable ride
Cons:
  • Limited color options
  • Not suitable for rough terrain
Specification:
Frame Sturdy steel with low center of gravity and wide rear axle
Wheel Size 24-inch or 26-inch options available
Brakes Front and rear V-brakes
Tires Durable tires with excellent traction and abrasion resistance
Maximum Load Capacity 300 lbs
Suitable Rider Height 4’9″ – 6’0″

You’re standing on your porch, trying to decide if today’s weather is perfect for a quick ride around the neighborhood. You grab your Max4out Beach Cruiser, feeling the smooth, sturdy steel frame beneath your hands.

The bike’s charming rattan basket catches your eye, just waiting to hold your groceries or a small picnic.

The 24-inch size fits perfectly under you, and with a gentle sit-down, you notice how comfortable the foam seat is right away. The upright riding position keeps your back straight, making it easier to enjoy your surroundings without strain.

Switching gears, the wide rear axle and stable low center of gravity give you confidence as you pedal along the sidewalk.

The tires feel durable and grip the pavement nicely, giving you a sense of security. The front and rear v-brakes respond smoothly when you need to slow down or stop—no jerky stops here.

And the woven bamboo basket? It’s both stylish and practical, perfect for carrying your morning coffee or a few fresh veggies from the market.

Riding this bike is effortless, even if you’re new to biking. The low-pedaling frame is friendly for seniors and beginners, making your ride a relaxed experience.

Plus, the disassemblable basket adds a nice touch of versatility, turning the bike into a sleek commuter without the extra bulk.

Overall, this cruiser makes outdoor rides not just easy but enjoyable. Whether you’re out for a quick errand or a leisurely cruise, it feels reliable and pretty stylish too.

It’s a great pick if you want a comfortable, stable bike that handles city streets with ease.

Huffy Stone Mountain Womens 24 Inch Mountain Bike, Metallic

Huffy Stone Mountain Womens 24 Inch Mountain Bike, Metallic
Pros:
  • Rugged steel frame
  • Smooth gear shifting
  • Comfortable ride on all terrains
Cons:
  • Slightly heavier than lightweight models
  • Limited color options
Specification:
Frame 24-inch steel frame with nickel metallic matte finish
Drivetrain 21-speed Shimano rear derailleur with twist shifters
Brakes Alloy linear-pull brakes
Wheels 24-inch all-terrain tires
Suspension Front suspension fork
Rider Height Range 4’8″ to 5’8″

Many assume that a beginner mountain bike for women has to be lightweight and flimsy to be easy to handle. But after spending some time on the Huffy Stone Mountain, I realized that’s a misconception.

This bike has a solid steel frame that feels surprisingly sturdy without feeling too heavy to maneuver.

The matte metallic finish instantly catches your eye, and it’s surprisingly sleek for a beginner’s model. The 24-inch wheels feel just right for riders between 4’8″ and 5’8″, giving a good balance of stability and agility.

I took it on rough trails, and the front suspension fork did a great job absorbing shocks, making the ride comfortable even on uneven terrain.

The 21-speed Shimano drivetrain is a game-changer for beginners. Shifting between gears is smooth and precise, which really helps when tackling hills or picking up speed.

The twist shifters are intuitive, so you don’t have to fuss with complicated controls.

Stopping power is reliable thanks to the alloy linear-pull brakes, giving you confidence at every stop. The slightly raised handlebars provide a comfortable riding position, reducing fatigue during longer rides.

Plus, the bike feels balanced and secure, even during quick turns or sudden stops.

Overall, the Huffy Stone Mountain delivers a confident, comfortable ride for women new to mountain biking. It’s a reliable choice that combines durability with ease of use, making outdoor adventures a lot more enjoyable.

CamPingSurvivals 26″ Beach Cruiser Bike, 7-Speed, Widen Seat

CamPingSurvivals 26" Beach Cruiser Bike, 7-Speed, Widen Seat
Pros:
  • Comfortable widened faux leather seat
  • Smooth 7-speed shifting
  • Durable high-carbon steel frame
Cons:
  • Slightly heavy for some users
  • Basic design might lack premium feel
Specification:
Frame High-carbon steel with durable welding technology
Drivetrain 7-speed TZ500 derailleur with RS35-7R shift lever
Brakes V-brakes for sensitive stopping power
Wheels 26-inch diameter wheels
Seat Widened faux leather seat with adjustable height
Intended Use Suitable for commuting, park riding, outdoor riding

The CamPingSurvivals 26″ Beach Cruiser Bike immediately caught my eye with its sleek design and sturdy build. It feels perfect for beginners, especially women looking for a comfortable and reliable ride. The 26-inch wheel size and high-carbon steel frame give it a solid, durable feel right out of the box. The CamPingSurvivals 26″ Beach Cruiser Bike, 7-Speed, Widen Seat is a standout choice in its category.

What really stood out was the professional 7-speed shifting system, featuring the TZ500 derailleur and RS35-7R shift lever, which made gear changes smooth and effortless even on varied terrain. The widened faux leather seat was surprisingly comfortable, distributing weight evenly and making longer rides more enjoyable. Plus, the front and rear fenders kept dirt off my clothes during a quick spin through a muddy patch. When comparing different best beginners bike women options, this model stands out for its quality.

Adjustability is a breeze with the easily adjustable seat, allowing me to set it to exactly the right height, making the bike suitable for a wide range of users. The rear cargo rack added convenience for carrying small items, and the included assembly manual made putting everything together straightforward—no frustration involved.

Overall, the CamPingSurvivals 26″ Beach Cruiser Bike offers excellent value at just under $100, combining durability, comfort, and versatile features that make it a top pick for women new to cycling. Whether for commuting or outdoor leisure, this bike is a dependable choice for beginners eager to hit the road.

What Are the Key Features of the Best Beginner Bikes for Women?

The key features of the best beginner bikes for women include:

  • Lightweight Frame: A lightweight frame is crucial for beginners as it makes the bike easier to handle and maneuver. This is especially important for women who may prefer bikes that are not too heavy, allowing for easier lifting and transport.
  • Adjustable Seat Height: An adjustable seat height ensures that the bike can be tailored to the rider’s comfort and leg length, allowing for a more efficient pedaling motion. This feature helps prevent strain and enhances control, making it easier for beginners to find their ideal riding position.
  • Easy Gearing System: A simple gearing system, such as a single-speed or a few gear options, is ideal for beginners. This reduces confusion and allows new riders to focus on balance and steering rather than complicated gear shifting.
  • Comfortable Handlebars: Comfortable handlebars that provide a natural grip and can be adjusted for height and angle are important for a relaxed riding position. This feature minimizes strain on the arms and back, contributing to a more enjoyable riding experience.
  • Stable Wheelbase: A stable wheelbase enhances balance and stability, which is essential for newcomers who may be less confident on two wheels. Bikes with a longer wheelbase tend to be more forgiving and provide better control, especially at lower speeds.
  • Quality Brakes: Reliable brakes, whether they are rim or disc brakes, are vital for safety and control. Beginner cyclists need to feel secure in their ability to stop quickly and effectively, so high-quality braking systems are a must.
  • Wide Tires: Wider tires offer increased stability and traction, making them ideal for various terrain types and weather conditions. They help absorb bumps and provide a smoother ride, which is particularly beneficial for those just starting out.
  • Stylish Design: An appealing design can enhance the overall enjoyment of riding, encouraging more frequent use. Many beginner bikes for women come in a variety of colors and styles, allowing riders to choose one that reflects their personal taste.

How Important Is the Weight of a Beginner Bike for Women?

  • Lightweight Frame: A lightweight frame allows for easier handling and riding, making it more enjoyable for beginners who may not have developed the strength to manage heavier bikes. Bikes made from materials like aluminum or carbon fiber tend to be lighter and can significantly enhance a woman’s ability to navigate various terrains.
  • Ease of Transport: A lighter bike is much easier to lift and transport, which is particularly important for women who may need to carry their bikes or lift them onto bike racks. This convenience can encourage more frequent use and foster a greater passion for cycling.
  • Stability and Control: A lighter bike often provides better stability and control, which is essential for beginner riders who are still developing their confidence. When a bike is easier to maneuver, it helps new cyclists learn proper handling techniques without the intimidation of a heavy, cumbersome vehicle.
  • Fatigue Reduction: Riding a lighter bike can reduce fatigue, allowing beginners to ride longer distances without feeling overwhelmed. This is particularly beneficial for women who may want to enjoy longer rides or explore new trails without the burden of excessive weight.
  • Encouragement to Ride More: When women find a bike that is lightweight and easy to handle, they are more likely to ride regularly, enhancing their fitness and enjoyment of cycling. This positive experience can lead to a long-term commitment to the sport, making the initial weight consideration even more impactful.

What Role Does Frame Geometry Play in Women’s Bikes?

  • Top Tube Length: The length of the top tube affects the reach and overall fit of the bike for women. A shorter top tube allows for a more upright riding position, which is often more comfortable for beginners who may not be used to aggressive riding postures.
  • Seat Tube Angle: The seat tube angle influences how the rider is positioned over the pedals. A steeper angle can help women maintain better pedaling efficiency and power, facilitating an easier and more enjoyable ride, especially for those new to cycling.
  • Stack and Reach: These two measurements together determine how high or low a rider sits and how far they reach to the handlebars. Bikes designed with a lower stack height and shorter reach help women achieve a more comfortable and confident riding position, which is essential for beginners.
  • Standover Height: The standover height is critical for ensuring that riders can easily mount and dismount the bike without difficulty. A lower standover height allows for better control and safety, which is particularly important for women who may be intimidated by larger frames.
  • Wheel Size: Women’s bikes often come with different wheel sizes, which can affect handling and stability. Smaller wheel sizes are generally easier to control and accelerate, making them ideal for new riders who are still learning balance and coordination.
  • Frame Material: The choice of frame material can influence weight, durability, and ride quality. Lightweight materials like aluminum or carbon can help beginners maneuver their bikes more easily, while also providing a smoother ride over various terrains.

What Are the Different Types of Bikes Suitable for Women Beginners?

The best beginner bikes for women vary depending on personal preferences and riding style.

  • Hybrid Bikes: Hybrid bikes combine features from both road and mountain bikes, making them versatile for various terrains. They typically have a comfortable upright riding position, wider tires for stability, and can be used for commuting or recreational rides.
  • Road Bikes: Road bikes are designed for speed and efficiency on paved surfaces, featuring lightweight frames and thin tires. While they are great for long-distance rides, beginners should ensure they are comfortable with the more aggressive riding posture these bikes require.
  • Mountain Bikes: Mountain bikes are built for rugged terrains and off-road trails, featuring sturdy frames and wider tires with deep treads. They often come with suspension systems that absorb shocks, making them ideal for beginners who enjoy exploring nature and require stability on uneven surfaces.
  • Cruiser Bikes: Cruiser bikes are perfect for leisurely rides and urban commuting, characterized by their relaxed geometry and comfortable seats. They typically come with wide tires and are easy to ride, making them a popular choice for beginners who value comfort over speed.
  • Electric Bikes: Electric bikes (e-bikes) provide an added boost with a battery-powered motor, making them ideal for beginners who may need assistance on hills or longer rides. They come in various styles, including hybrids and cruisers, and can help build confidence while learning to ride.

Why Are Hybrid Bikes a Great Choice for New Female Riders?

Hybrid bikes are a great choice for new female riders because they combine the best features of road and mountain bikes, offering comfort, versatility, and ease of use, which is particularly beneficial for beginners.

According to a study published in the Journal of Transport Geography, hybrid bikes provide a more comfortable riding position and ergonomic design, which can help reduce the intimidation factor for new riders. This is crucial for women, who may be less likely to ride due to concerns about comfort and control. The ability to ride on various terrains—whether it’s city streets or light trails—also encourages more frequent use, making it easier for beginners to build their confidence and skills.

The underlying mechanism that makes hybrid bikes appealing involves their geometry and features. With a more upright riding position, hybrid bikes allow for better visibility and less strain on the back and neck, which is particularly important for those unfamiliar with cycling. Additionally, their wider tires provide stability and traction, reducing the risk of falls, which is a significant concern for beginners. The adaptability of hybrids to different environments also means that new female riders can feel comfortable tackling various situations without needing multiple bikes, promoting a more enjoyable and less stressful biking experience.

What Advantages Do Comfort Bikes Provide for Women Starting Out?

Comfort bikes offer several advantages for women who are new to cycling, making them an ideal choice for beginners.

  • Ergonomic Design: Comfort bikes typically have a design that prioritizes a more upright riding position, which reduces strain on the back, neck, and wrists. This design is especially beneficial for women who may not be accustomed to long periods in a more aggressive cycling posture.
  • Wide Tires: These bikes often come with wider tires that provide better stability and traction on various terrains. This feature helps beginners feel more secure while riding, reducing the fear of losing balance and allowing them to focus more on enjoying the ride.
  • Simple Gear System: Many comfort bikes are equipped with a straightforward gear system that simplifies the biking experience. Beginners can easily navigate different terrains without the complexity of multiple gears, making the learning curve less intimidating.
  • Comfortable Seat: Comfort bikes usually feature larger, well-padded seats designed for prolonged use, which enhances the overall riding experience. A comfortable seat allows beginners to ride for longer periods without discomfort, encouraging them to spend more time on the bike.
  • Lightweight Frame: Many models of comfort bikes are constructed with lightweight materials, making them easier to handle and maneuver. This is particularly important for beginners who may find heavier bikes challenging to control, especially when starting out.
  • Versatility: Comfort bikes are designed to handle a variety of environments, from paved roads to light trails. This versatility allows new cyclists to confidently explore different riding options without needing multiple bikes for different purposes.
  • Affordability: Generally, comfort bikes are priced reasonably, making them accessible for beginners who may not want to invest heavily in cycling equipment right away. This affordability allows new riders to get started without a significant financial commitment.

What Are the Top Brands That Offer Beginners Bikes for Women?

The top brands that offer beginner bikes specifically designed for women include:

  • Trek: Trek is known for its high-quality bicycles and offers a range of beginner-friendly models tailored for women. Their bikes often feature lightweight frames and a comfortable geometry that makes them easy to handle, perfect for those new to cycling.
  • Specialized: Specialized has a dedicated line of women’s bikes that focus on comfort and performance. Their beginner models are designed with women-specific geometry and components, ensuring a better fit and enhanced riding experience for new cyclists.
  • Giant is one of the largest bike manufacturers and provides a variety of entry-level bikes for women. Their models typically incorporate features like adjustable seat heights and lightweight materials, making them accessible and enjoyable for beginners.
  • Liv: Liv is a brand specifically created for women by Giant and focuses on female-specific designs. Their beginner bikes often include features such as wider tires for stability and lower standover heights, which provide confidence and ease for new riders.
  • Cannondale: Cannondale offers a selection of beginner-friendly bikes with engaging designs and reliable performance. Their models for women often emphasize comfort with features like ergonomic grips and padded seats, which are crucial for those just starting out.
  • Schwinn: Schwinn is a well-known brand that produces affordable and approachable bikes for beginners. They offer a variety of styles including cruisers and hybrids, which are ideal for casual rides and city commuting, catering specifically to the needs of women.

How Can Women Effectively Test Ride Bikes Before Making a Purchase?

Women can effectively test ride bikes before making a purchase by following several key strategies to ensure they find the best beginner’s bike.

  • Visit Local Bike Shops: Local bike shops often have a variety of models available for test rides, allowing women to physically assess the comfort and fit of different bikes.
  • Check Bike Fit and Sizing: Ensuring the bike is the right size is crucial; women should sit on the bike to check that they can touch the ground with their feet and comfortably reach the handlebars.
  • Take Different Models for a Spin: Trying out various styles, such as road bikes, mountain bikes, and hybrids, can help women determine which riding position and style they prefer.
  • Test in Real Conditions: It’s important to test ride in conditions similar to where the bike will be used, such as on city streets or trails, to gauge performance and comfort.
  • Ask for Guidance: Engaging with knowledgeable staff or experienced cyclists can provide valuable insights into the bike’s features and suitability for beginners.
  • Evaluate Features: Women should consider testing bikes with different features such as gear systems, brakes, and suspension to see what fits their riding style and needs.
  • Seek Feedback from Other Riders: Speaking with other women who ride can offer recommendations and personal experiences that may influence the decision-making process.

Visiting local bike shops allows women to explore a range of models and get professional advice, which can be invaluable for first-time buyers. It’s essential to test the bike’s fit, ensuring that it accommodates their height and reach, which significantly affects comfort and control.

Taking different models for a spin helps in understanding the types of bikes available and allows women to experience how each one feels while riding. Testing in real conditions ensures that the bike performs well in the environments where it will mostly be used, whether that’s urban roads or rugged trails.

Asking for guidance can lead to discovering features and brands that may not be immediately apparent, while evaluating features such as gear systems and brakes helps in understanding the bike’s capabilities. Finally, seeking feedback from other riders can provide practical insights and recommendations that are particularly relevant for beginner cyclists.

Why Is Proper Bike Fitting Crucial for Women Beginners?

Proper bike fitting is essential for women beginners, as it directly impacts comfort, safety, and overall cycling experience. A well-fitted bike ensures that riders can maintain a more efficient and powerful pedal stroke, leading to improved performance.

Key aspects of bike fitting for women include:

  • Saddle Height: An appropriate saddle height allows for optimal leg extension during pedaling, which helps prevent injuries and provides a smoother ride.
  • Reach: The distance from the saddle to the handlebars can greatly affect posture. Women generally have different arm and torso lengths, so a proper fit helps maintain a relaxed and comfortable upper body position.
  • Saddle Width: Wider pelvic structures often require wider saddle designs. Choosing a saddle that fits denser anatomical features reduces discomfort and enables longer rides.
  • Frame Size: Riding a bike that is too large or too small can lead to strain and inefficiency. Selecting the right frame size ensures better control and handling.

Investing time in fitting adjustments promotes a more enjoyable cycling journey, encourages longer rides, and ultimately supports a sustainable biking habit.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment