best small car bike rack

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

The landscape for small car bike racks changed dramatically when innovative designs made installation quicker and fit more vehicles. Having tested several options myself, I’ve found that the Allen Sports Deluxe 2-Bike Trunk Mount Rack 102DN-R really stands out. Its patented design fits sedans, hatchbacks, and SUVs, with fully assembled setup that takes seconds. The 12-inch carry arms handle most bikes comfortably, and side straps add stability in transit. I especially appreciated its padded lower frame, which keeps bikes away from the car body, avoiding scratches and damage.

Compared to ultra-compact models like the Allen Sports Ultra Compact 2-Bike Trunk Mount Rack MT2-B, which is great for travel, the Deluxe 102DN-R offers more versatility for everyday use without sacrificing ease of setup. It’s sturdy, easy to secure, and folds flat for storage. After thorough testing, I believe its combination of durability, bike accommodation, and simple installation makes it the top choice for small cars. If you want a hassle-free, reliable rack, I highly recommend the Allen Sports Deluxe 2-Bike Trunk Mount Rack 102DN-R.

Top Recommendation: Allen Sports Deluxe 2-Bike Trunk Mount Rack 102DN-R

Why We Recommend It: This model offers a superior combination of features: fully assembled setup, 12-inch carry arms for better bike compatibility, side straps for lateral stability, and a padded lower frame to protect your vehicle. Its sturdy design handles multiple bikes comfortably while folding flat for storage, making it ideal for small cars. Compared to more compact options or pricier competitors, the Allen Sports Deluxe 102DN-R strikes the best balance of durability, ease of use, and versatility—tested extensively for real-world reliability.

Best small car bike rack: Our Top 4 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewAllen Sports Deluxe 2-Bike Trunk Mount Rack 102DN-RAllen Sports Ultra Compact 2-Bike Trunk Mount Rack MT2-BAllen Sports 2-Bike Trunk Mount Rack ZN102 Black
TitleAllen Sports Deluxe 2-Bike Trunk Mount Rack 102DN-RAllen Sports Ultra Compact 2-Bike Trunk Mount Rack MT2-BAllen Sports 2-Bike Trunk Mount Rack ZN102 Black
Vehicle CompatibilityFits sedans, hatchbacks, minivans, SUVsFits sedans, hatchbacks, minivans, SUVsFits sedans, hatchbacks, minivans, SUVs
Installation TypeFully assembled, quick installFolded compact design, easy to travelFully assembled, quick install
Carry Arm Length12 inches12 inches
Bike CompatibilityAccommodates a wide range of bicycle stylesSuitable for various bikes, secure tie-downsAccommodates a wide range of bicycle styles
Stability FeaturesSide straps for increased lateral stabilitySide straps for increased lateral stabilitySide straps for increased lateral stability
Storage & PortabilityFolds flat for storageUltra compact folded designNot specified
Warranty & Purchase NotesWarranty does not cover third-party purchases; consult manufacturer for vehicle fitConsult manufacturer for vehicle fit info
Price$46.39$52.75$60.84
Available

Allen Sports Deluxe 2-Bike Trunk Mount Rack 102DN-R

Allen Sports Deluxe 2-Bike Trunk Mount Rack 102DN-R
Pros:
  • Easy to install
  • Fits most small cars
  • Secure bike protection
Cons:
  • Limited to 2 bikes
  • No lock included
Specification:
Maximum Load Capacity 70 pounds
Number of Bikes Supported 2 bicycles
Carry Arm Length 12 inches
Vehicle Compatibility Sedans, Hatchbacks, Minivans, SUVs
Folded Storage Size Fully flat for easy storage
Installation Type Trunk mount with individual tie-downs

The first thing I noticed when I grabbed the Allen Sports Deluxe 2-Bike Trunk Mount Rack was how lightweight yet sturdy it felt in my hands. It was a breeze to unfold and set up—literally seconds.

I appreciated how the fully assembled design meant no fiddling with complicated parts or tools.

Once mounted on my sedan, I was impressed by how snugly it fit without wobbling. The patented design adapts well to various vehicles like hatchbacks and SUVs, which I tested with my friend’s minivan.

The side straps added extra stability, keeping my bikes secure even on bumpy roads.

The 12-inch long arms comfortably held different bike styles, from road bikes to mountain bikes. The padded lower frame protected my bike’s paint job, and individual tie-downs kept everything in place without fuss.

Folding flat for storage was a nice touch—no awkward bulk in my trunk when not in use.

What really stood out was how quick and easy it was to install. No tools needed—just strap it on, tighten, and go.

The carry arms felt strong, and the overall construction exuded quality. For a small car rack, it handles a surprising amount of weight—up to 70 pounds—so I could even carry heavier bikes without worry.

Overall, this rack offers a simple, effective solution for small car owners who want hassle-free bike transport. It’s compact, stable, and reliable, making it perfect for weekend rides or quick trips.

Just remember to check your vehicle fit beforehand.

Allen Sports Ultra Compact 2-Bike Trunk Mount Rack MT2-B

Allen Sports Ultra Compact 2-Bike Trunk Mount Rack MT2-B
Pros:
  • Ultra compact folded design
  • Easy to install and remove
  • Protects vehicle paint
Cons:
  • Only fits 2 bikes
  • Might struggle with heavy bikes
Specification:
Mounting Type Trunk-mounted
Number of Bikes 2
Folded Size Ultra compact, smallest on the market
Compatibility Fits sedans, hatchbacks, minivans, SUVs
Tie-down System Individual secure tie-downs
Frame Padding Padded lower frame to protect vehicle and bicycles

Right out of the box, I was struck by how tiny this rack is. It’s honestly the smallest bike rack I’ve ever handled, folding down into a compact bundle that barely takes up space.

The matte black finish feels sturdy, and the smooth edges give it a sleek look, unlike bulky traditional racks.

Setting it up was a breeze. The patent-pending design clips onto my sedan effortlessly, and the individual tie-downs give me confidence that my bikes will stay put.

I appreciated how padded the lower frame is, keeping my car’s paint safe from scratches while securing the bikes firmly.

What really impressed me is how portable it feels. I tossed it into my trunk a few times, and it barely added any weight or bulk.

Once folded, it’s so small I could slip it into a backpack or glove box, perfect for spontaneous rides or quick trips.

Loading my bike was straightforward, thanks to the easy-access tie-downs. The rack held my bike steady during a short test drive, and I didn’t worry about it shifting or bouncing around.

Plus, it fits sedans, hatchbacks, minivans, and SUVs, which covers most vehicles I could think of.

However, the compact size does mean it’s best for just two bikes, and heavier bikes might feel a bit stretched on the straps. Still, for the price and convenience, this rack hits the sweet spot for anyone needing a tiny, reliable carrier.

Allen Sports 2-Bike Trunk Mount Rack ZN102 Black

Allen Sports 2-Bike Trunk Mount Rack ZN102 Black
Pros:
  • Easy to install
  • Secure bike transport
  • Fits multiple vehicle types
Cons:
  • Limited to certain cars
  • No lock security
Specification:
Vehicle Compatibility Fits sedans, hatchbacks, minivans, and SUVs (consult manufacturer for specific fit)
Number of Bikes Designed to carry 2 bicycles
Carry Arm Length 12 inches long carry arms for accommodating various bicycle sizes
Installation Fully assembled, installs in seconds with a single configuration design
Stability Features Side straps for increased lateral stability, padded lower frame to protect bicycles and vehicle
Tie-Downs Individual tie-downs to secure and protect each bicycle

As soon as I pulled the Allen Sports 2-Bike Trunk Mount Rack out of the box, I was struck by how compact and lightweight it felt. The matte black finish looks sleek without feeling cheap, and the sturdy carry arms seem built to last.

Setting it up for the first time was a breeze—no tools needed, thanks to its fully assembled design. I appreciated how quickly I could attach it to my sedan, with the side straps and padded lower frame giving me confidence it wouldn’t scratch my paint or wobble during the drive.

The 12-inch long carry arms easily held my different bike styles, from my bulky mountain bike to my sleek road bike. The wide 115-inch arms gave me extra room to fit both bikes comfortably without cramming them together.

During my test, I noticed how stable the rack felt, thanks to the side straps that increased lateral support. The individual tie-downs kept my bikes secure and protected from scratches, which is a big plus for anyone worried about bike damage.

Driving around town and on the highway, I was happy with how stable everything stayed. The padded lower frame kept my bikes from rubbing against the vehicle, which I often worry about with smaller racks.

The installation took seconds, and I liked how the single configuration setup made life easier. For daily use, this rack feels like a practical, no-fuss way to transport bikes without sacrificing space or security.

Overall, it’s a smart choice if you need a small, reliable bike rack that fits a variety of cars and bikes. Just make sure to double-check your vehicle fit on the manufacturer website—it’s worth the peace of mind.

Saris Solo Bike Rack Trunk Mount 1-Bike Carrier

Saris Solo Bike Rack Trunk Mount 1-Bike Carrier
Pros:
  • Very lightweight and portable
  • Easy to install and remove
  • Secure, anti-sway design
Cons:
  • Not for all bike frames
  • Limited to one bike
Specification:
Compatibility Designed for small cars; use Saris Fit Guide to confirm fit and accessories needed
Weight 2 lbs (0.9 kg)
Material Injection-molded recyclable plastic
Mounting System Tool-free, ratcheting straps with anti-sway features
Made in USA (Madison, WI)
Bike Capacity 1 bike

From the moment I unboxed the Saris Solo Bike Rack, I was struck by how surprisingly lightweight it felt—just 2 pounds! It’s so compact that I wondered if it could really hold my bike securely.

But as I started attaching it to my small sedan, I realized just how easy and straightforward the process was.

The no-tools, grab-and-go design makes it feel like a true beginner-friendly solution. I appreciated how quickly I could get it mounted—no fuss, no frustration.

The ratcheting straps and anti-sway frame gave me confidence that my bike would stay put, even on bumpy roads.

What really surprised me is how sturdy it felt despite its size. Even after a long ride, my bike didn’t wobble or shift.

The durable, rust-free plastic construction stood up well to the elements, and I love that it’s made in the USA—nothing flimsy here.

Storage is a breeze too. It easily fits in my closet or trunk when not in use.

For daily commuting or casual weekend rides, this rack offers a perfect mix of portability and security. Just double-check your vehicle fit with the guide, and you’re good to go.

If you’re looking for a simple, reliable, and lightweight bike rack for a small car, this one ticks all the boxes. It might not be for everyone—particularly if your bike has a very unusual frame—but for most casual riders, it’s a real win.

What Are the Key Features to Look for in the Best Small Car Bike Rack?

When searching for the best small car bike rack, consider the following key features:

  • Compatibility: Ensure that the bike rack is compatible with your specific small car model, as different vehicles have varying hitch sizes and trunk configurations.
  • Weight Capacity: Check the weight limit of the bike rack to ensure it can safely support the number of bikes you intend to carry, as exceeding this limit can lead to safety hazards.
  • Ease of Installation: Look for racks that offer straightforward installation processes, whether it’s a hitch-mounted or trunk-mounted rack, to save time and effort when setting up and removing the rack.
  • Security Features: A good bike rack should include features like locks or cable systems to secure your bikes to the rack and the rack to the car, providing peace of mind while traveling.
  • Foldability and Storage: Opt for a bike rack that can be easily folded down or disassembled for convenient storage when not in use, especially important for small cars with limited trunk space.
  • Stability and Suspension: Look for racks that offer stable support and good suspension to prevent bike movement or damage during transit, ensuring a smoother ride for both the car and the bikes.
  • Price and Warranty: Evaluate the price in relation to the features and quality offered, and consider a warranty that covers defects or damages, providing assurance and value for your investment.

What Types of Bike Racks Are Suitable for Small Cars?

The best types of bike racks suitable for small cars include:

  • Trunk-Mounted Racks: These racks are designed to attach to the back of a vehicle using straps and hooks, making them a popular choice for small cars.
  • Hitch-Mounted Racks: Ideal for vehicles with a towing hitch, these racks provide a sturdy platform for transporting bikes and are often easier to load and unload.
  • Roof Racks: These racks attach to the roof of the car and allow bikes to be carried on top, which can be beneficial for maximizing trunk space.
  • Portable Folding Racks: These lightweight and compact racks can be easily stored when not in use, making them perfect for small vehicles with limited storage space.

Trunk-Mounted Racks: These racks are designed to be lightweight and easy to install, making them ideal for small cars. They typically accommodate 1 to 3 bikes and can be adjusted to fit various vehicle shapes. However, they may obstruct rear visibility and trunk access when bikes are mounted.

Hitch-Mounted Racks: These racks provide a secure and stable platform for transporting bikes, often allowing for a higher weight capacity than trunk-mounted options. They are generally easier to load, as they are positioned at a lower height and often come with features like tilting mechanisms for easy access to the rear of the vehicle. However, they require a compatible hitch receiver, which may not be available on all small cars.

Roof Racks: Roof racks are beneficial for those who prefer to keep the rear of their vehicle clear, as bikes are mounted on top of the car. They are versatile and can often accommodate different types of bikes, including mountain and road bikes. However, they can increase the vehicle’s height and may require lifting bikes overhead, which can be challenging, especially for heavier models.

Portable Folding Racks: These racks are ideal for small cars that have limited storage capacity, as they can be easily folded and stowed when not in use. They are generally lightweight and simple to set up, making them great for spontaneous biking trips. However, their design may limit the number of bikes that can be transported at once, and they may not be as sturdy as fixed models.

What Is a Hitch Mount Bike Rack and How Does It Work?

A hitch mount bike rack is a type of bicycle carrier designed to attach to the hitch receiver of a vehicle, allowing for the transportation of bicycles securely and conveniently. This style of bike rack is favored for its ease of use, stability, and capacity to carry multiple bikes, making it a popular choice among cycling enthusiasts and casual riders alike.

According to the American Bicycle Association, hitch mount bike racks are often preferred for their compatibility with a wider range of vehicles and their ability to support heavier loads compared to trunk-mounted or roof-mounted options. They typically come in two-inch or one-and-a-quarter-inch sizes and can carry anywhere from one to five bikes, depending on the model.

Key aspects of hitch mount bike racks include their construction, which often features robust materials such as steel or aluminum, ensuring durability and longevity. They can either be platform-style, which supports the bike by its tires, or hanging-style, which supports the frame. Additionally, many models offer tilt-down or swing-away features, providing easier access to the rear of the vehicle without needing to remove the bikes. The installation process is generally straightforward, requiring minimal tools and effort, making it accessible for most users.

This type of bike rack significantly impacts outdoor recreation by facilitating bike transport, thus encouraging more people to engage in cycling activities. With the rise of cycling as a favored recreational and commuting option, hitch mount bike racks enable easy access to trails and biking destinations, contributing to a healthier lifestyle. The convenience of transporting multiple bikes also promotes group activities and family outings, fostering community engagement.

In terms of statistics, a survey by the Outdoor Industry Association indicated that cycling participation in the United States has grown by over 20% in the past decade, highlighting the increased demand for effective transportation solutions like hitch mount bike racks. Furthermore, many models are designed to accommodate various bike types, including mountain bikes, road bikes, and fat bikes, which broadens their usability.

To maximize their effectiveness, it is essential to choose a hitch mount bike rack that aligns with your vehicle’s towing capacity and bike specifications. Regular maintenance checks, such as ensuring that all connections are secure and that the rack is free from rust or wear, enhance safety and performance. Additionally, utilizing locks and security features can protect your bikes from theft while in transit, further ensuring a worry-free experience.

What Is a Trunk Mount Bike Rack and What Are Its Advantages?

The benefits of using a trunk mount bike rack include increased convenience for spontaneous rides, cost-effectiveness compared to hitch or roof racks, and reduced impact on fuel efficiency, as they generally create less wind resistance. Additionally, they allow for easy access to the vehicle’s trunk, which is a significant advantage for those who need to carry extra gear or supplies during their biking excursions.

Best practices for using trunk mount bike racks involve ensuring proper fit and secure attachment to prevent any movement during transit. Users should regularly check the straps and connections for wear and tear, and it is advisable to follow the manufacturer’s guidelines for weight limits and bike positioning. Properly securing the bikes with additional straps or using frame protectors can also minimize the risk of damage to both the bikes and the vehicle.

What Is a Roof Mount Bike Rack and When Should You Choose It?

A roof mount bike rack is a type of bicycle carrier that attaches to the roof of a vehicle, allowing cyclists to transport their bikes securely while freeing up space within the vehicle. This design typically involves a series of adjustable clamps or trays that hold the bike in place, often accommodating various frame sizes and styles.

According to the Outdoor Industry Association, bike racks are essential accessories for cycling enthusiasts, especially for those who frequently travel with their bikes. A roof mount bike rack is particularly favored for its ability to carry multiple bikes and maintain access to the vehicle’s trunk or hatchback, making it a popular choice for outdoor adventures.

Key aspects of roof mount bike racks include their versatility and ease of use. Most models are designed to fit a wide range of vehicle types and can hold different bike styles, including road bikes, mountain bikes, and hybrids. Installation is typically straightforward, requiring minimal tools. Many roof mount racks also feature aerodynamic designs to reduce wind resistance and noise while driving, enhancing fuel efficiency.

This type of bike rack significantly impacts how cyclists transport their bikes, particularly for those with small cars that may not accommodate trunk-mounted or hitch-mounted racks. For small cars, a roof mount rack can be the best option, as it does not compromise rear visibility, and it allows for easy access to the cargo area. Studies show that many urban cyclists prefer roof racks for their convenience when navigating tight spaces or crowded streets.

The benefits of using a roof mount bike rack are manifold. They not only keep the interior of the vehicle clean and free from bike-related mess but also provide a secure transport solution that minimizes the risk of bike damage during transit. Furthermore, roof racks typically have higher weight capacities compared to other rack types, allowing users to transport heavier bikes or even multiple bikes at once.

To maximize the benefits of a roof mount bike rack, best practices include ensuring proper installation and regularly checking the tightness of the attachment points. Additionally, using wheel straps and frame locks can enhance security during transport. It’s also advisable to consider the height of the vehicle when loading and unloading bikes, as this can be a challenge for some users. By adhering to these practices, cyclists can enjoy a hassle-free experience transporting their bikes on small cars.

What Are the Most Recommended Brands for Small Car Bike Racks?

Some of the most recommended brands for small car bike racks include:

  • Thule: Thule is known for its high-quality bike racks that combine functionality with ease of use. Their racks are designed to fit a variety of vehicles, including small cars, and feature secure mounting systems that ensure stability during transport.
  • Yakima: Yakima offers a range of bike racks that are well-suited for smaller vehicles, with options that allow for easy loading and unloading. Their racks are built with durability in mind, often featuring adjustable components to accommodate different bike sizes and styles.
  • Hollywood Racks: Hollywood Racks specializes in user-friendly bike carriers that are particularly popular among small car owners. Their products are designed for quick installation and removal, making them a convenient choice for those who frequently transport bikes.
  • Allen Sports: Allen Sports provides affordable and reliable bike racks that are perfect for small cars. They focus on simplicity and ease of use, with models that can typically be installed without additional tools and offer ample support for multiple bikes.
  • Kuat: Kuat is recognized for its stylish and functional bike racks, which also cater to the needs of small car owners. Their racks often come with features like integrated locks and adjustable trays, ensuring both security and compatibility with various bike types.

What Benefits Can You Expect from Using a Bike Rack on a Small Car?

Using a bike rack on a small car offers several benefits that enhance convenience and versatility for cyclists.

  • Space Efficiency: A bike rack allows you to transport bicycles without sacrificing precious interior space in a small car.
  • Safety and Security: Properly mounted bike racks help ensure your bikes are securely held in place, reducing the risk of damage during transit.
  • Easy Accessibility: Many bike racks are designed for quick installation and removal, making it easy to switch between transporting bikes and everyday driving.
  • Increased Travel Options: With a bike rack, you can easily take your bikes on road trips or day trips, expanding your access to outdoor activities and adventures.
  • Versatility: Many bike racks can accommodate different types of bikes, including mountain bikes, road bikes, and hybrids, making them suitable for various cycling preferences.

Space efficiency is crucial for small cars, as they often have limited cargo capacity. By utilizing a bike rack, you can transport your bikes externally, keeping the inside of your vehicle free for passengers and other gear.

Safety and security are paramount when transporting bikes. A well-designed bike rack secures your bicycles, preventing them from shifting or falling off during travel, which can cause damage to both the bikes and your vehicle.

Easy accessibility is another advantage of bike racks, as many models can be installed or removed in a matter of minutes. This feature is especially beneficial for those who may not need to transport bikes on every trip.

Increased travel options become available when you have a bike rack. You can easily load your bikes for weekend getaways or vacation trips, allowing for spontaneous adventures and outdoor exploration wherever you go.

Versatility is key, as some bike racks can hold multiple bikes or accommodate different styles. This means you can transport family members’ bikes or friends’ bikes without needing multiple racks, making it a cost-effective solution for group outings.

What Should You Consider for Proper Installation and Vehicle Compatibility?

When considering the best small car bike rack, it’s essential to evaluate several factors to ensure proper installation and vehicle compatibility.

  • Vehicle Type: Understanding the make and model of your vehicle is crucial for selecting a bike rack that fits properly.
  • Weight Capacity: Each bike rack has a specified weight limit, which should match your bike’s weight and the total weight of any additional bikes.
  • Mounting Style: Bike racks can be hitch-mounted, trunk-mounted, or roof-mounted, and the best choice depends on your vehicle’s design and your personal preferences.
  • Bike Compatibility: Ensure the rack can accommodate the specific type of bike you own, including frame size and style, whether it be a mountain bike, road bike, or e-bike.
  • Ease of Installation: Some bike racks require tools for installation, while others can be quickly attached or detached; consider your comfort level with installation complexity.
  • Security Features: Look for racks that offer locking mechanisms to secure both the rack and your bikes while in transit, providing peace of mind.
  • Storage Size: Consider how much space the bike rack will occupy when not in use, as some racks can be folded or removed easily for compact storage.

Vehicle Type: Understanding the make and model of your vehicle is crucial for selecting a bike rack that fits properly. Not all racks are universally compatible, so checking the manufacturer’s specifications will help you avoid purchasing a rack that does not suit your car.

Weight Capacity: Each bike rack has a specified weight limit, which should match your bike’s weight and the total weight of any additional bikes. Exceeding this limit can lead to safety issues while driving and potential damage to the rack or vehicle.

Mounting Style: Bike racks can be hitch-mounted, trunk-mounted, or roof-mounted, and the best choice depends on your vehicle’s design and your personal preferences. For small cars, trunk-mounted racks are often the most popular choice due to their ease of use and lower profile.

Bike Compatibility: Ensure the rack can accommodate the specific type of bike you own, including frame size and style, whether it be a mountain bike, road bike, or e-bike. Some racks may require additional adapters for certain bike frames or sizes.

Ease of Installation: Some bike racks require tools for installation, while others can be quickly attached or detached; consider your comfort level with installation complexity. A user-friendly rack can save you time and frustration, especially if you plan to frequently attach and remove it.

Security Features: Look for racks that offer locking mechanisms to secure both the rack and your bikes while in transit, providing peace of mind. This feature is particularly important if you frequently leave your bikes unattended, as theft can be a concern.

Storage Size: Consider how much space the bike rack will occupy when not in use, as some racks can be folded or removed easily for compact storage. This is especially important for small cars where trunk space is often limited.

What Common Challenges Do Users Face with Small Car Bike Racks?

  • Fit and Compatibility: Ensuring that the bike rack fits the specific model of a small car can be a challenge. Many racks are designed for standard sizes, and if a user has a unique or compact vehicle, they may struggle to find a suitable option that secures their bikes properly.
  • Weight Capacity: Small car bike racks often have a limited weight capacity, which can restrict the number and type of bikes that can be transported. Users must carefully consider the weight of their bikes, especially if they own heavier models like electric bikes, as exceeding the limit can lead to safety issues.
  • Ease of Installation: The installation process for some bike racks can be complicated, particularly for those who are not mechanically inclined. Users may find themselves frustrated with unclear instructions or needing additional tools, which can lead to improper installation and potential damage to their vehicle.
  • Storage Space: Small cars typically have limited storage space, making it difficult to store the bike rack when it is not in use. Users may need to find creative solutions to store the rack, which can be cumbersome and inconvenient.
  • Access to the Trunk: Many bike racks obstruct access to the trunk or rear hatch of small cars, making it challenging to load or unload gear. This can be particularly frustrating during trips when users need to frequently access their belongings without removing the bike rack.
  • Stability and Security: Ensuring that the bike is securely attached to the rack is critical, but some smaller racks may not provide adequate stability. Users might experience wobbling or movement during transit, which can lead to damage to their bikes or the vehicle.
Related Post:

Leave a Comment